Senior Vice President and Chief Administrative Officer · AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP, Inc. (AFG)

Michelle Gillis

A named executive officer of AMERICAN FINANCIAL in every fiscal year CompBrief holds from FY2016 to FY2020. Every figure below is printed as the company filed it and cited to the filing it came from.

Total disclosed compensation, FY2020

$1,029,354

Salary $425,077Stock awards $320,063

FY2019: $1,082,589

5th of 7 named executive officers at American Financial by FY2020 total.

7 named officers on file for AMERICAN FINANCIAL, FY2020

Michelle Gillis’s pay file — $29

  • 5 fiscal years of pay, line by line
  • 3 equity grants, each cited to its filing
  • AFG’s disclosed peer group of 13 companies

A PDF and a CSV sent to your email. Every row is cited to its filing.

One-time report. No refunds.

See an example →

Velarion Intel · free for 3 days · no card

See how AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s whole pay program stands against its peers

  • AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s company dashboard and its AI-written, board-ready brief, every figure cited to the filing
  • Peer-group intelligence, custom peer reruns and governance screens
  • Every other company we cover, with alerts when they file
Start my free trial on AFG→

No card. Nothing is charged, and the trial ends on its own.

Compensation figures as of the proxy filed April 2, 2021 (DEF 14A). Insider transactions since that proxy, current to 2026-11-20.

Free

Get Michelle Gillis’s pay history as a PDF, right here and by email

The PDF adds what this page leaves out: up to 10 years of pay, a peer comparison, and the board on one page. Two emails at most, nothing else.

Michelle Gillis compensation by year

AMERICAN FINANCIAL Summary Compensation Table · all 5 fiscal years held
In US dollars, as AMERICAN FINANCIAL reports it. Most recent year shaded. Totals are the company’s disclosed totals.
ComponentFY2016FY2017FY2018FY2019FY2020
Salary$332,315$342,354$355,979$390,770$425,077
Bonus$0$0$0$0$0
Stock awards$300,026$300,303$320,522$320,162$320,063
Option awards$0$0$0$0$0
Non-equity incentive$330,173$297,500$314,040$310,174$232,933
Pension and deferred compensation$0$0$0$0$0
All other$55,287$52,587$57,557$61,482$51,281
Total$1,017,801$992,745$1,048,098$1,082,589$1,029,354

Each year as stated in that year's proxy. A dash means the company reported no figure in that column. Source: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP, Inc. DEF 14A filed April 2, 2021, accession 0001140361-21-011395, and prior-year filings. Open the filing on EDGAR.

How this page was built: the AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP, Inc. filed document, accession 0001140361-21-011395. Every figure is read from that document and cited to the page and table it appears in. Filed April 2, 2021.

$1.0M
$993K
$1.0M
$1.1M
$1.0M
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
SalaryNon-equity incentiveStock awardsAll other

Equity holdings

unvested awards at FY2020 year-end
TypeUnvested unitsValue at year-endExercise price
RSU3,225$282,575—
RSU3,180$278,632—
RSU3,070$268,993—
RSU2,840$248,841—

Per the Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End table in AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP, Inc.'s FY2020 proxy; value at the fiscal year-end close, as the company printed it.

Insider transactions since the last proxy

18 Form 4 lines since the FY2020 proxy (filed April 2, 2021)
current to 2026-11-20 · updated nightly
DateTransactionPlanSharesPriceHeld after
2026-06-24Sale—2,247$139.0013,135
2026-02-26Grant or award—3,012$0.0015,382
2026-02-23Tax withholding—730$129.8512,370
2025-12-29Gift—542$0.0011,454
2025-02-23Tax withholding—885$120.1713,100
2025-02-19Grant or award—3,282$0.0013,985
2024-12-24Gift—735$0.0011,996
2024-03-01Sale—2,053$126.8148,553.83

The 8 most recent of 18 lines, each as reported on the Form 4. "10b5-1" marks a trade the filing reports under a pre-arranged trading plan. View every Form 4 filing on EDGAR →

AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s named executive officers, FY2020

as the company reported each
Named executive officerRoleFY2020 total
Carl LindnerCo-Chief Executive Officer and Co-President (Co-Principal Executive Officer)$9,631,170
S. Craig LindnerCo-Chief Executive Officer and Co-President (Co-Principal Executive Officer)$9,596,241
John BerdingPresident of American Money Management$4,318,061
Vito PerainoSenior Vice President and General Counsel$1,858,574
Michelle Gillis · this pageSenior Vice President and Chief Administrative Officer$1,029,354
Brian HertzmanSenior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer$759,428
Joseph ConsolinoFormer Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer$560,235

The full AMERICAN FINANCIAL compensation record

free company brief

This page is one person within AMERICAN FINANCIAL's record. The company brief lists every named executive, each linking to their own page.

Peer companies

named in the AMERICAN FINANCIAL proxy · each links to its own free brief

Compensation, the day it’s disclosed

The CompBrief Daily Digest lists the newest executive and director compensation disclosures as companies file them.

How this record is built

Every figure on this page is one figure from a public SEC filing, printed as the filing states it and cited to the document. Compensation totals are AMERICAN FINANCIAL's own disclosed totals, not summed by Velarion. Insider transactions are read from Form 4 filings and cover every line filed since the most recent proxy. Nothing is estimated by Velarion; where the company does not disclose a value the cell reads "—", and a section appears only where the company discloses the data. Corrections: records@velarion.ai.

Michelle Gillis's compensation dossier · One-time report. No refunds.